xTY3x's art Reviews on Newgrounds

[Heisenberg]

do you mean Heisenberg, from Breaking Bad? anyway nice caricature.

Izzy-A responds:

oh, I was way off

[Dylan Dog fanart]

ottimo lavoro

come al solito. le uniche cose che non mi convincono sono la faccia di dylan, che sembra un po' più vecchio e consunto del normale e le dita della morte, che sembrano più robotiche che scheletriche. comunque un fantastico uso dei colori. è ispirato a qualche episodio in particolare?

orathio89 responds:

naa, nessuno. in effetti se ci passavo un pò più tempo poteva pure venire più caruccio, ma alla seconda ora ero svogliato. XD oltre al fatto che Dylan Dog in sè lo detesto.

[good ol ranx]

ora tocca a me

veramente incredibile per un lavoro da venti minuti, sei un grande. toglimi una curiosutà , hai frequentato o frequenti un corso di disegno?

orathio89 responds:

Feci il liceo artistico a suo tempo, ma a parte le occasioni di pratica tutti i giorni non ti dava granchè. la vera gavetta si fa da soli, specie sul digitale dove nessuno sa neanche cos'è. E' ancora grosso modo territorio vergine dalle nostre parti. In pratica siamo pionieri :D

[Zanardi]

i got it

a very interesting and sharp revisitation of the great character created by Andrea Pazienza.

orathio89 responds:

che esattamente 23 anni fa ci lasciava... ci manchi Paz

[08]

your best

i've looked at all the other pages and i can say for sure this one is the best. not only the drawing, the composition and the choose of colors are wonderful, but also the story, his thoughts, the way they are expressed and the depth they reach are incredible. you remember me moebius, you know? he's amazing and you're on the good way. keep it up.

d-z responds:

Thanks, I love him, but I'm a long way from that.

[Archer]

better

this one is way better than the other. the only thing i can point out is the excessive lenght of her left arm. other than that the design is quite original and particular.

einharjar responds:

you sir are now my art critic..haha..thanks..
btw, you should also practice anatomy your drawings are a little off...

[Merc]

nice

but the head is way too small and the general desing is pretty unoriginal and flat. you should focus on details and peculiar elements to make unique your characters.

einharjar responds:

thanks for the advise...with that said i really need to practice alot!!!

[Chihana Holiday 2010]

nice

though i don't like manga style, i like your coloring and the details you put in it. the thing that disappoint me is the perspective: looking at the four characters on the left i would say the "guest" is laying on the floor, but then you look at the guy on the right and that perspective just doesn't make sense.

JustinianKnight responds:

I agree, there really isn't any perspective to this, I just liked arranging them this way. The background was really just something I added later on.

[Katie]

great detail

but it's way too unproportioned: the eyes are too large and so the nose, while the mouth, the right cheek and the chin are too small. the neck is so thin it seems it can barely resist the weight of that massive head. i guess you started drawing without sketching, didn't you? because all these problems are easy to avoid with a good sketch wich can give you the right distances and dimensions of all the elements.

ken9000 responds:

It's not supposed to be a photograph. It's an interpretation of her face. I made certain choices to accentuate various features. It's closer to caricature than an exact 1:1 render, which I felt would be boring. The fact that you think I don't know how to draw a face is pretty damn insulting.

[Blue horse]

this ain't my kind of style

but i have to admit that the horse is just wonderful, the lights and the shades are extremely realistic. also the land is good, to me the only thing that ruins this piece is the sky: the moon isn't as good as the rest (maybe it shouldn't have been so dark) and i think it's way to large. i understand you wanted to give a fantasy atmosphere to your piece, but in this composition i would have preferred a small moon in the corner, watching the horse from a long distance, it would have given a sense of depth, wich your piece lacks. anyway the horse is so good that i almost suspect it's traced; i hope not.

emiliapaw5 responds:

Thanks, I had a horse book for reference, I don't trace. My composition is off, but I think the moon might be a personal preference.